It is whammy to see the institutions prattling until the slobber drops out from their mouth for each other. Also, they seems to be exempted from the moral convulsion to realise the misery of the poorer. Such a whirlpool since decades has raised a question that whether Pakistan is suitable for democracy or not? Therefore, as per the interminable crisis think tanks should need to re-visit the structure of democracy which is placed in Pakistan.
Democracy in Pakistan faces many challenges and is characterized by various aspects of dysfunction. Here are some examples. Political Instability: Pakistan has a history of political instability and frequent regime changes. Military coups have occurred routinely throughout the country's history, with the military controlling, directly or indirectly, much of its existence. Weak Institutions: Pakistan's democratic institutions, including the judiciary, civil service, and police, are weak and vulnerable to political interference. This has led to a lack of accountability and a culture of impunity. Corruption: Corruption is an ongoing problem in Pakistan's democratic system, and allegations of corruption often affect senior officials and politicians. This undermines public trust in governments and democratic processes. Ethnic and sectarian tensions: Pakistan is a multi-ethnic and multi-religious society, creating tensions between various groups. These tensions are often exploited by politicians to their advantage, leading to further polarization and division. Limited Representation: Pakistan's democratic institutions have often failed to represent the interests of marginalized groups such as women, minorities and rural people. This creates a lack of inclusion and further marginalizes these groups. Overall, Pakistani democracy is characterized by many dysfunctional aspects that undermine its effectiveness, legitimacy, and ability to serve its people.
Historical Context:
Democracy in Pakistan has faced many challenges since its founding in 1947. These challenges are rooted in the country's historical background of military regimes, corruption, and ethnic and religious tensions.
Pakistan's early years were marked by political instability as the country struggled to establish a democratic system of government. The country's first constitution, adopted in 1956, established parliamentary democracy, but it was short-lived. In 1958, General Ayub Khan's army seized power in a coup that overthrew the constitution. This was the beginning of a long military regime in Pakistan.
Pakistan's military regime has been characterized by a lack of accountability, corruption and political repression. Military rulers often justified their rule by saying that only they could ensure law and order and ensure national security. However, her rule was marked by human rights violations and a lack of political freedom.
Pakistan faced a serious crisis in 1971 when East Pakistan, separated from West Pakistan by India, declared independence and became Bangladesh. This was the result of years of political and economic discrimination against East Pakistan by the West Pakistani ruling class. The war that followed severely damaged Pakistan's military and political establishment, ushering in a period of introspection and debate about the country's future.
In 1973, Pakistan adopted a new constitution establishing a federal parliamentary democracy. But the country's democratic experiment was short-lived. In 1977, General Zia-ul-Haq seized power in another military coup, suspending the constitution and imposing martial law. Zia-ul-Haq's rule was marked by a crackdown on Islamic conservatism and political opposition. He introduced Islamic laws such as the Hudood Ordinance, which stipulated harsh penalties for crimes such as adultery and theft. He also banned political parties and imprisoned opposition leaders.
Zia-ul-Haq death in a plane crash in 1988 resulted in a period of political unrest and frequent regime changes. Pakistan's democratic system has become increasingly corrupt and dysfunctional, with politicians using their seats of power to enrich themselves and their families. The military continued to play a strong role in Pakistani politics, frequently intervening to oust the elected government it viewed as a threat to national security. The military's influence was further strengthened by its control over key institutions such as the judiciary and the media.
Ethnic and religious tensions have also played an important role in Pakistani politics. The country is home to various ethnic and religious groups such as Punjabis, Sindhis, Balochs, Pashtuns, Mohajirs, Muslims, Hindus, Christians and Sikhs. These groups often compete for political power and resources, leading to tension and violence. Additionally, Islamist extremism is a growing problem in Pakistan, with extremist groups such as the Taliban and al-Qaeda operating in the country. These groups have carried out numerous terrorist attacks against civilians, military personnel and politicians.
Its impact on Citizen:
The challenges to Pakistan's democracy have had a profound impact on the country's citizens. Here are some examples of how these challenges have affected the lives of ordinary Pakistanis.
Limited access to basic services:
Corruption and lack of accountability in Pakistan's democracy limit access to basic services such as health care, education and clean water. Marginalized communities and rural populations are disproportionately affected.
Political instability:
Frequent changes in government and political instability undermine public confidence in the democratic process, making it difficult for citizens to plan for the future. This is also creating a sense of uncertainty and insecurity, especially for those who depend on stable governance for their livelihoods.
Human rights violations:
The military regime and political repression have caused numerous human rights violations in Pakistan, including extrajudicial killings, enforced disappearances and torture. This abuse affects a wide range of citizens, including political activists, journalists, and members of minority communities.
Economic uncertainty:
Pakistan's democracy is struggling to cope with the country's economic challenges, including poverty, unemployment and inflation. As a result, many citizens struggle to make a living and have limited opportunities for social and economic mobility.
Security concerns:
The threat of terrorism and political violence has left many Pakistanis feeling anxious and frightened. Citizens have been targeted by numerous terrorist attacks, including bombings, shootings and suicide bombings.
Overall, the challenges facing democracy in Pakistan are having a profound impact on its citizens, affecting their access to basic services, their sense of security, and their ability to fully participate in the democratic process. Addressing these challenges requires continued efforts to improve accountability, strengthen democratic institutions, and address the root causes of national instability and insecurity.
Alternative Solution
Addressing the challenges facing democracy in Pakistan requires a multi-pronged approach involving a range of stakeholders, including governments, civil society and the international community. Here are some alternative solutions that can help strengthen Pakistani democracy.
Strengthening democratic institutions:
Pakistan's democratic institutions such as the judiciary, civil service and police must be strengthened and become more independent. This could include reforms to increase their autonomy, improve their capacity and reduce political interference.
Fight Corruption:
Corruption is a major obstacle to Pakistani democracy and must be addressed through a range of measures, including legal reform, transparency initiatives and anti-corruption campaigns. This could include strengthening the role of regulators, such as the National Accountability Office, and improving the legal framework to hold corrupt officials accountable.
Election reform:
Pakistan's electoral system needs to be reformed to make it more transparent, inclusive and fair. This could include measures such as improving the accuracy of electoral rolls, improving voter education and participation, and reducing the impact of money and sponsorship in elections.
Inclusion and Minority Rights:
Democracy in Pakistan needs to become more inclusive and representative, especially for marginalized communities such as women, minorities and rural residents. This could include measures such as increasing the representation of these groups in government, improving access to basic services and protecting their rights and freedoms.
Addressing ethnic and religious tensions:
Pakistan needs to address the root causes of ethnic and religious tensions, including discrimination, economic inequality and political exclusion. This could include actions such as promoting interfaith dialogue, improving economic opportunities for marginalized communities, and strengthening the role of civil society in promoting tolerance and understanding.
International support:
The international community has an important role to play in supporting democracy in Pakistan through initiatives such as providing technical and financial support for institutional strengthening, promoting human rights and the rule of law, and fostering political dialogue and reconciliation. can be fulfilled.
In summary, addressing the challenges facing democracy in Pakistan requires sustained efforts and a range of solutions that address the root causes of instability, corruption and political exclusion. By working together, the government, civil society and the international community can build a more inclusive, transparent and accountable democratic system that represents the interests of all Pakistani citizens.
Written by Tayyab.
0 Comments